Wise Guys - Appleton

The best deep dish pizza around. Order ahead to avoid the wait. Great environment and always good beer.

We went here the first time about a week ago and for the first time in a long time we found a place where servers actually pay attention to customers. The stuffed crust pizza was SO good and was way bigger than expected, the mozzarella sticks not the best I would not pay $10 for them again. Will definitely be there again maybe in a week or two cause I seen several things on the menu I wanted to try.

Atmosphere: Located in a strip mall off of Oneida next to a little game shop. There is a good amount of parking and the inside is quite large despite the outside appearance. They have a few patio seats outdoors for the warmer months. The inside is quite dark. There is a long bar area right when you walk in and then there is a dining area with booths and tables. Some of the booths against one wall have curtains, which is nice if it is loud (which it was VERY loud) and you want some privacy on your night out. Service: They seemed a bit understaffed, but the servers did a great job trying to make sure we had everything we needed. Our server was extremely personable and we were grateful for a wonderful evening out. Food: First off, we came here because we were looking for good onion rings, and the image on yelp looked amazing, but don't be fooled, they don't have onion rings on there menu (insert frown here). Despite that glitch, HOLY. MENU. I seriously don't know where to begin, this menu is huge. It took us forever to decide what we wanted. My fiance ended up selecting their Donny burger (sausage patty and beef patty with marinara and cheese) with fries, and I chose the Coco Calzone. Both of us were beyond pleased with the selections we made, and it will be hard to order other items off the menu in the future. Their french fries are so finger licking good, whatever seasoning they use packs flavor and they are crispy as all get out. I can't wait to come back here-I'm hoping it is sooner than later.

Fantastic pizzas!! This place clearly stands out for the pizza that they serve. Our orders Calpone pizza Fried fish Spinach and Artichoke dip Sangria and beers. Capone pizza One with the Alfredo sauce and the other zesty.Both were immensely great especially the thin crust. Toppings well spread and delicious. The large serves 3 people and the small was good for 2. Excellent portions. The fish was served with baby potatoes and was a good addition to the menu. However, I have had better Friday fish fry. The surprise on the menu was the Spinach and Artichoke dip. Definitely a must have dish. It was mouth watering. The only Con was the waiting time. It was a busy night so we had to wait for 30 minutes. Great service, good food and how can i forget Sangria was epic too!

I love this Pizza. They lay it on like it should be. Their cheese is different than most. It tastes more high-end than the normal commercial mozz. It's buttery, heavy. The sauce is just right and plenty of it. Homemade crust starts it off. The oven looks like something special. The manager-owner-bossman takes pride in his pies. Have to say I love their big bag fries. Give them a try.1 more thing. Tastes great cold or nuked the next day.