The Islander - SHELTER ISLAND

The Islander is a great, classic, diner! The staff is friendly, the food is good, and the atmosphere is classic. I recommend the 'Stinky ' burger.

Our gang goes there every Saturday for breakfast. Our favorite hang out.

Loved! To me is a place that I would go back many times.

The best place. I have not been disappointed in years!

I gave them 1 stars instead of 1 because they were one of the few places on the island open for lunch. That said, the fish and chips contained very little actual fish, and that cod was frozen rather than fresh. like the ferries, they only take cash. If you’re passing through, just plan to eat on either side of this island, or if not, skip this place. Bring lots of cash if you try it.