El Potro - Saint Augustine Beach

The food was outstanding and the service was prompt!

Just a side note: they don't serve hard alcohol since they're located in a school, but they do offer beer and wine. Enjoy a relaxing lunch or dinner with them—you won't be disappointed!

I want to extend my gratitude to the locals and community leaders who rated this restaurant five stars. Any negative experiences mentioned are clearly isolated incidents. The food here rivals my favorite spot back home, and honestly, if I lived closer, it might just take the top spot. Our server was a young woman who was incredibly attentive and friendly. The frozen margarita was delicious and really set a festive tone for my wife and me on our anniversary trip. The flavors in my El Potro Fajitas were outstanding, and my wife was thrilled with her chicken Texas rice, even with the added vegetables. The salsa had a surprising sweetness that I initially underestimated, but its complex flavors really shone through. The perfect kick at the end of each bite delighted our palates. Don’t pay attention to the negative reviews—this place was bustling even on a Monday night!

This little Mexican place was brilliant!! The server was very nice and attentive to its customers. I felt very comfortable when I first came to St.Agustine. Great price 100% authentic Mexican cuisine. If I ever have a chance to come back, that's my first stop. Thank you. Tony L. For your great service.

We were staying across the street of here. We could smell the amazing food. So glad we tried it out. Huge portions, amazing taste, great service. Probably one of the best Mexican Restaurants I have had. We could tell they were reall deal by the homemade hot sauce.