Five Star Pizza - Orange Park

Five Star Pizza was fantastic! Their pizzas are enormous, and I also tried their garlic rolls—those were amazing. The prices are quite reasonable, too. I definitely recommend this excellent pizza place. Oh, and I almost forgot to mention that they deliver until 3 AM!

Overall, I really enjoyed their pizza and will probably order from them again. It has that classic New York-style thin crust, which is slightly doughy—a texture I personally love. The pizza is also loaded with cheese. The only thing preventing me from giving them a full 5 stars is the uneven distribution of toppings. Some slices were packed with toppings, while others had very few. I would have preferred a more consistent topping distribution, but it was still delicious pizza.

Ordered from this location during the day, I didnt take pictures but they did an alright job. About 3/5 for day time. Seemed way more slapped together during the day, obviously they are more busy but, no excuses. Night time tho, is what you guys are seeing in the pics. They did a great job 2 times so far at night, 1-3am. 5/5 stars, which evens it out to my review of 4/5. Night shift takes the win. Day shift racks-a-disiprine.

I absolutely love 5 Star Pizza! It's the most affordable spot for extra-large pizzas, and they're delicious! I also appreciate that my orders are always ready quickly. They made my brother-in-law's birthday a special occasion!

Get it with extra dough—it's absolutely delicious! This is definitely the best pizza place around!