Tin Fish - Newburgh

This is the best fish restaurant in the Tri-State area. The seafood is always fresh, and the service is exceptional.

I sat there and really didn’t enjoy the experience at all. The food was mediocre at best, and the prices were way too high. I hated having to wait in line just to place our order; if we’re paying that much for a sit-down dinner, I expect better service. Our total for three of us was $74 for cold food, which was really disappointing. We definitely won’t be going back. The black crab cake wasn’t impressive, and there was cabbage on the plate that didn’t add anything to the meal. Overall, it just wasn’t good for us.