Beth I's Pies - Montague

The sugar cream pie was hands down the best I've ever tasted. It was incredible! Thank you, Beth I's!

My husband and I visited your bakery today after seeing a post about it on Facebook. We really enjoyed the small tart pie and the cheesecake. Additionally, the lady who served us was kind enough to make a special small lemon meringue pie for my husband while we waited, and he absolutely loved it—he ate it in the car before we even left the parking lot. We're very happy customers!

I absolutely love the crust on her pies! In all my 50+ years, I’ve never enjoyed pie crust because it always seemed so heavy and greasy. My husband ordered one of her pies, and I took a small piece, expecting to dislike it as usual. To my surprise, it was delicious! I could have happily eaten just the crust on its own. You definitely need to try one of her treats; you won't be disappointed! -Tina Claypool

Love their pies! Don't have a favorite because they are all so good!!

I wanted a cheesecake for husband's birthday, but the bakery was closed on Tuesdays. However, after I messaged them, the kind lady met me there and handed me a cheesecake! I am so very thankful: by the way, it was also delicious!!!!