Stefano's Italian Cafe - Middletown

I wasn't particularly fond of pizza, but every other dish I ordered was outstanding. The shrimp, mussels, noodles, and sauce created one of the most delicious meals I've ever experienced in a restaurant. I can't recall the name of the dish, but it was truly exceptional. The service was consistently good, and the prices are very reasonable. The atmosphere is lovely; you almost lose track of your surroundings while dining here. I highly recommend trying this place if you haven't yet!

I had dinner at this restaurant again, and it never fails to impress. I truly enjoy the food, and the service is outstanding.

Stefano offers a fantastic dining experience! The appetizers and main dishes are superb. The staff is attentive and well-informed. Whether you're looking for a casual meal or a special date night, Stefano is the perfect choice!

I've been there for years. Excellent food and atmosphere. Makes other Italian foods seem generic. I highly recommend Stefanos.

I only get to my old home town of Middletown a couple times a year but when I do, a stop here is a MUST. Incredible food, service and atmosphere. It just can’t get any better.