Southernmost Key Lime Shop - Key West

During our stay at Andrews Inn and Garden Cottages, conveniently located just behind the Southernmost Key Lime Shop, we discovered this lovely shop while wandering back from our adventures in Key West. The staff were incredibly friendly and helpful. Although it was quite late, I was delighted to find they still had hot tea available (with milk). We enjoyed the shop so much that we decided to return the next day to try some slices of the famous Key Lime Pie, and it certainly lived up to its reputation! We even took a few more slices back home with us to West Palm Beach. I highly recommend this place, and I look forward to returning one day for more Key Lime Pie and tea.

In addition to serving delicious slices and whole pies, along with a variety of desserts, this place offers a fantastic selection of key lime merchandise. You'll find not just desserts, but also marinades, sauces, and spice rubs. Plus, there’s a section dedicated to Key West-style clothing.

The title of the review sums it up perfectly. It’s undoubtedly the best key lime pie I’ve ever tasted. The shop also offers a variety of other items if you're looking for something different.

Title of the review says it all. Without a doubt the best key lime pie I've ever had. The store also has several other things to buy if you want something else.

Despite the fact we have tried KeyLime Pie at Petite Provence in Portland and it was very good, their pie is above and beyond. Highly recommend it.