Pizzaro's - East Stroudsburg

I ordered a veggie roll (as part of a pick up order) on 8/16/24. I Ate through maybe 1/3 of the way when I realized that I had a foreign object in my mouth. I pulled out some kind of long strip of plastic or something amongst the ricotta cheese. It was after closing so I called as soon as they opened the next day. I asked for the owner and was told he wasn't there. I asked for a manger, again no one there. She asked what was wrong and I told her. She sounded completely unaffected and disinterested. I asked her to take my name and number and have someone call me back, she claimed she did yet I never heard from ANYONE. It's been a week. I've tried calling 2 more times with the same result. I never finished my food obviously and I took photos and have both the plastic piece and my uneaten portion still wrapped in my fridge. I've been a patron for the 23yrs I've lived here. These past few years they have declined significantly and this? This is beyond bad quality, its negligence.....this goes to just plain bad ownership, management etc. They never even called me back. They have the same demeanor as the girl who answered the phone. I could have choked, if it was a child eating it, they could've choked and then this Google review would be the least of their problems. I paid $12 for that disaster roll. I would like my money back!

They were swamped with orders but they were awesome. Pizza was delicious and the sandwiches were so good.

Pizzaro’s is our go-to pizza place! The food is great and the service is even better! They get to know their regular customers and they treat us very well. I think this is the best pizza place in the general area and I’m always disappointed if I go anywhere else. We keep coming back and always will!

The pizza is super good, the quality is consistent, and I like the choices of their to-go slices. Great New York Style pizzas, but anything on the menu is great, as they do it all well. It is a hidden gem in this region.

Pizzaro’s is the best pizza and Italian in East Stroudsburg. We order from here all the time, from pasta dishes to subs to pizza they knock it out of the park every time.