Pizza Cellar - Crown Point

The pan pizza here is incredible—it’s the best local pizza I’ve ever had, and I’ve tried quite a few!

I was searching for a family-owned pizza restaurant and came across this one. After reading the reviews, I decided to give it a try. The owner was very engaging and certainly delivered on his promises. The pizza was excellent. While it is a bit pricier, quality is worth the extra cost. I would definitely recommend it to family and friends. Great job, PizzaCellar!

I visited Pizza Cellar based on a friend's recommendation, and it was absolutely delicious! The crust is a delightful combination of buttery tenderness and a crispy edge. The sauce has a complex flavor that perfectly balances sweetness, acidity, and herbal notes. The homemade sausage is a fantastic blend of high-quality pork and spices, making the offerings from other pizza places seem mediocre in comparison. The fresh ingredients are excellent, and the chefs do a great job of caramelizing the cheese. Remarkably, this outstanding pizza is only a few dollars more than those from discount pizza restaurants. Additionally, Pizza Cellar's Italian beef and Italian sausage sandwiches are the best in town—just make sure to order extra jus because they're quite large. No matter what you choose, you will not be disappointed!

Awesome pan pizza! Quick and delicious. We took advantage of the special got 2 mediums and received 1 small pan for free. The pan was a bit better than the thin crust. Sausage tasted top quality. Very tasty sauce. Good amount of cheese. Highly recommend.

Hands down the best pizza in Northwest Indiana!! Closest thing to the pizza joints in Chicago that are the best!! The owner takes pride in his food and it shows!!