Howards Cafe - Brookhaven

The last time I was here before tonight was a few years ago and boy did the food go downhill. I ordered the chicken cordon blue and it was disappointing. The cutlet was bordering on burnt and the gravy was from a can. It was too salty and had an odd taste. For my side I ordered the pasta with garlic and oil. Pasta was overcooked and was sitting in a puddle of grease. My boyfriend ordered the London broil. The meat was tender but was swimming in a puddle of canned brown gravy and canned mushrooms that were just thrown on top. The dining room was old and dirty looking and service was ok. I'm not sure where all of the 5 stars are coming from. I won't be eating there ever again!!

I discovered this hidden gem while off the beaten path. The steak sandwich was outstanding, and the teriyaki chicken was just as delicious. Their cheeseburgers are amazing, and they have the best mozzarella sticks I’ve ever had! Every meal comes with a salad, which is a nice touch. The prices are unbeatable, and I can’t recommend this place enough! Oh, and I was thrilled to find High Noon for just $3.50!

Have been going there for years. Great value for your money. Food is always excellent. Owner and staff very friendly. Best marinated steak around. Love going there due to great owner/staff and food. A on my review.

So far this has been a good experience, we come from Lindenhurst to eat here probably 2 maybe 3 times a month. We've been coming here for about 4 months now . It's nothing fancy , BUT THE SERVICE IS GREAT last nite our waitress was named Michelle and it was amazing. The food is always cooked to order .

I used to love this place because I enjoyed their burgers. However, my husband ordered the hot open turkey plate, and my friend had the hot open roast beef plate. Both dishes had very little meat and were only warm instead of hot. To my surprise, I found out they were using Boar's Head cold cuts, which seemed overpriced for what we received. Unfortunately, I won't be returning.