Pier Fifty-three Open Air Brick Oven

Tried this place while out on a little local road trip. This restaurant is one of the only options in the area. It is located on Lake Ontario about 5 minutes from chimney bluffs park. There is plenty of parking across the street and tons of seating both inside and outside. There is a large food menu and you go to the bar to order. There is a very large selection of drinks at the bar as well. We decided to try two pizzas: the hell fire and the honey mustard chicken, both were really good and tasty. Pricing was a little steep but likely due to the remote location. Looks like it can get busy during the summer with live music but we went there on a Saturday the first weekend in June and there wasn't many people there. Worth a stop for lunch or a drink if in the area. Friendly staff. Dogs are allowed at outdoor seating. They even have water bowls inside on a shelf that you can use.

I used to love this restaurant, as they had delicious food. However, I'm not sure what happened, but I have been disappointed with the food this year. I would suggest trying somewhere else.

New staff and new items on the menu! They are excited to see everyone… Can’t wait to visit… they have made all kind of changes!

Usually a fun atmosphere...and that's still true, however food and drink quality left a lot to be desired this trip. The pizza was uncooked in the middle, You ran out of rolls which eliminated or changed a handful of menu items. I was shocked at how small the drink portions were .....for the steep price...tiny. bar person clearly never made a Manhattan and when I nicely told her she didn't offer anything including an apology.

Awesome place. Pulled pork pizza is worth the drive. But the ambiance right on the water makes it one of our favorites in the area.