Castiglia's Italian Eatery - Winchester

No frills — made-from-scratch Italian meals, pizza and sandwiches in a homey and unassuming spot off the beaten path.

It was a little hard to find because the sign outside says 'Pizzamore '. The interior is outdated but the food was fresh and tasted good, and very reasonably priced (except $15 for chicken parm). The waitress wasn 't super enthusiastic and didn 't have much prepared but it was okay.

Hit upon this restaurant by accident and so glad we did...authentic Sicilian Italian food with the best bread in the world...very fresh seafood...we eat here about once a month and linger to enjoy every bite!..I would venture to say the best Italian I have ever had!..

Food was awesome. Staff was kind and very polite. We will be back!

The best Italian food on a casual atmosphere. Food it's always fresh and delicious. This place is my home away from home. Mmmm