Casey's General Store - Winamac

I tried calling the restaurant multiple times—at 7:30 PM, 7:35 PM, 7:40 PM, 7:45 PM, 7:50 PM, and finally at 8:00 PM—but no one picked up. All I wanted was a pizza.

The only issue I have with the Winamac Casey's is that they're frequently out of items in their soda cooler. Otherwise, the food and service are great. Food: 4/5, Service: 5/5, Atmosphere: 5/5.

I had the worst pizza experience at the Winamac store. The crust was extremely thin, and the service was lacking. They told me it would be ready in 35 minutes, even though there were no other orders. When I returned 40 minutes later, they were surprised that I was already back. I will never order from there again.

Decent pizza but I called to have it delivered. When I told her where I needed it delivered, she said we don't deliver there but if you give us a really big tip we will. She could have just said no and I would have drove the 10 minutes to go get it. Just thought it would be easier since I have a kid who needs to get ready for school tomorrow.

Pizza was as wonderful as always!! Very nice people working there!