Oscar's Frozen Custard - West Allis

My family has been a fan of your custard since the very beginning! It's our top choice whenever we go out for our favorite treat. My brother had his first job here over 20 years ago, it's my go-to spot for a burger and a shake, and my mom calls in for 1-2 half gallons of her favorite flavors a few times a month! However, my only concern is that in recent months, no one has been answering the phones. For example, tonight (8/31/22), I called four times starting just after 8 PM, but the phone just kept ringing without an answer each time. I ended up calling the Waukesha location just so I could reserve some of today’s flavor for pickup tomorrow, and they answered right away. I hope this issue can be resolved easily because we truly love Oscar's Frozen Custard, and I would love to give you the five-star rating you rightly deserve!

This used to be someplace I liked to go that had decent food? that has clearly changed. Dined there today after not having been there in awhile, food was very low grade, looked bad and tasted even worse. I was starving and I still couldn?t stomach it all-it was that hard to get down despite all the grease. Felt so sick right after eating the burger, and stomach is crampinghorribly. Never going back ????

Stopped in this location yesterday on the lunch hour. I have to say that the first thing I noticed was the camaraderie of the staff. They all seemed happy and moved with hustle! Dion took my order and was very pleasant and kind. Thanks Dion! The food wasgreat and the custard was over the top! Overall great experience. Sandy Heinz

We really love this location and visit it frequently! The burgers and custard are consistently delicious. It tends to be a bit busy in the afternoons, but we never have to wait long for our food.

I want to share my experience at Oscar's on Hwy 100, a restaurant I visit frequently but haven't reviewed in a while. First and foremost, the staff at the counter are exceptional. They took my order quickly, with a friendly smile, and ensured everything was accurate. The food was served hot and absolutely delicious. The grill cooks clearly know what they're doing; the burgers, cheese curds, and onion rings were grilled and prepared to perfection. Even after bringing the meal home, just two miles away, everything was still warm. I highly recommend supporting this restaurant, as they genuinely care about their customers' satisfaction.