Gerry's Italian Kitchen - Watertown

Excellent Chef Salad in Town. Made by AlexFood: 5/5

Came in from out of town and just straight up didn’t get my pizza. Ordered it at 8:55, got a confirmation text saying it should be there around 9:45:9:55 and 10:35 rolls around and nothing. Tried calling numerous times and no answer. I understand if you’re short staffed, and it’s Easter weekend, but my god at least answer the phone and give paying customers an update. Terrible service.

Great local place have been going since I have been a kid. Food is somewhat inconsistent but still a go to spot.. some of the workers could deal with little customer service but besides that you get what you get kinda pricy but heyFood: 3/5

Been going downhill for years. They just don't listen they've given up. The owner is just not receptive any criticism

My brother-in-law ordered three pizzas, two Caesar salads, and some garlic bread for delivery. The delivery time was impressive; it actually arrived 15 minutes earlier than expected. Unfortunately, the food itself was disappointing. The Caesar salad had stale croutons that were nearly inedible, and the dressing was lackluster, more reminiscent of Italian dressing than the traditional creamy Caesar. The pizzas had very little red sauce, and one of them was overloaded with barbecue sauce. The garlic bread was probably the best-tasting item, but even that was quite mediocre. My brother-in-law had a good experience with pizza from this restaurant in the past, so we were hopeful for a repeat, but overall, we were all left feeling disappointed.