Maguire's Bayfront

If you come to Fire Island, you must visit this place. Always packed with fun people, great food drinks.. You will definitely enjoy your time. I have been coming here for years!

Definitely enjoyed my first meal. The food was great paid with cash and was charged as surcharge which the waiter pocketed. I questioned them about it and they told me as for using a credit card, I paid in cash took me 3 days To get ahold of someone eventually they sent me. A should have offered me a free something or other for this mistake. It's not ok to over charge ppl .... and when I asked in person I was blown off by personnel....had to call FYI PPL IF Y PAY CASH WATCH OUT! SEE THE PICTURE

They cut me and my boys off from the bread after like 6 loaves, but otherwise an incredible experience. Absolutely recommend you go here, just don’t ask for more than 5 servings of bread. They’ll cut you off. Get the ahi tuna instead

The place is overpriced and overrated. The only good thing is the sunset but you can enjoy that from anywhere on the pier. The bread is raw cooked, waiters are over worked and hence irritated. The food is nothing to

Macguires is a lively eatery that isn't too expensive, especially if you're a bit low in cash after the ferry ride to Fire Island in the first place. We had the best waitress! She was very nice, informative, and social! She was very patient, as we were a big group and took a while to order. I ordered the Bungalow burger, and everyone got a small sliver of watermelon on their plate along with their entree. Highly recommend!