Cellaio Steak - Village of Monticello

Just tried it for the first time this week and I love it. The entire experience was amazing and totally exceeded my expectations. The waitress made us feel like VIP's and literally checked on every aspect of our dinner. She made suggestions and gave us an alternative side so we had something different to try. They also recognized our anniversary which was totally unexpected and made our evening even more special. I will be back outside of restaurant week. So glad I gave it a chance.

This is my fourth time here and every time we have had a great experience. The food is always five stars so just expect really good food! I always get steak but tonight I had the duck and it was cooked perfectly. My 16 month old enjoyed the crab legs and duck and loved the carrots!! Tyler was our waiter and he made our experience extra special! I honestly have to say he was the best waiter we have ever had! Extremely informative, kind and paid attention to all the fine details. I needed paper napkins because you moms know how toddlers can be and they left the restaurant to get paper napkins!! They also brought out a dessert for my husbands birthday which was so amazing!! Just amazing all around!!! Thank you!!!

Dark, noisy dungeon that’s waaaaay overpriced. For a “steakhouse,” you’d think they would have it down but what they brought to me was like what you’d get at Denny’s. Except that for this kind of money I could have thrown a birthday party for 12 at Denny’s. Don’t waste your time. Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $100+ Food: 1 Service: 1 Atmosphere: 1

We had Rudy as our waiter and he was absolutely on point the entire night. The drinks were also fantastic. My party had the lobster vodka pasta, steak, lobster tail. The lobster tail was the best thing hands down. The pasta was loaded with lobster which made the price somewhat worth it. However, the pasta itself lack some flavor. For $60 I would expect a better tasting pasta. I didn't try the steak but was told it hasn't bad at all. Pull apart rolls as the appetizer was pretty good as well.

Truly a top notch steakhouse. Our steaks were cooked to the right temperature. Service was great. We will definitely visit again. Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $100+ Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5