Papa's Pizza Oven Hamburg

Overall the pizza was pretty good. One think we would say is that the sauce was not evenly spread. Some bites on the end of the slice were just cheese and dough. Also, we did ask for it well done and it was not. Even though it was not, it was still a very solid pizza. We will definitely be back ?

Waited an hour and 15 minutes and paid $30 for a burnt pizza. Burnt, chewy and couldn't taste any sauce. I've heard so many good things so I was excited and decided to wait the 75 minutes. What a let down ?

I'm from the northtowns where sweet sauce is common, and have tried many kinds. Among my favorite is Pizza Oven in Lockport, which is known for their sweet sauce, thin crust pizza. This place is the first in the southtowns to bring sweet sauce pizza down here, and I was sadly disappointed. The pizza seems overpriced for what it is, was not fully cooked in the middle, and I agree with the overwhelming majority consensus that the sweet sauce here is FAR too sweet. Tasted like is was eating sugary fried dough with cheese and pepperoni on top. Sadly couldn't taste the tomato sauce at all through the buckets of sugar added. A successful sweet sauce has a balance. You guys need to tone it down on the sugar, and cook your pies better for longer. If the sweet sauce is tweaked to reduce the sugar, might try this place again. Otherwise, no chance.

We have found our favorite place to get pizza and wings ! Well worth the trip from West Seneca and I would advise anyone living within West Seneca/Orchard Park and surrounding areas to try it, you will not be disappointed ! The owner John came out and was super nice. FYI, they’re working on getting the new signage too. If I could leave 10 stars I would ??

As a national food reviewer for all new restaurants that open and I have been to a lot of them and I will say this the sauce to cheese ratio and seasoning was spot on the wings were just amazing and I will say this to anyone who wants awesome food and a killer price come check out papas pizza oven in Hamburg NY on sunset