Pizza Paul's - Village of Geneseo

I love supporting small business, but time in and time out, of almost three years of living here, this shop has progressively gone down hill. The lakeville one is usually pin point and I’d suggest using that one, over the Geneseo one. It’s very clear the staff are lacking proper training. The Pizzas are good but anything else is a mess. Especially the wings from there. But mostly, just disappointed in the people they keep allowing to represent their facility.

We had a large order for delivery tonight. The delivery arrived before scheduled time. All the food was hot, fresh and made to order. Everything was delicious. We were very pleased and would highly recommend! ?

Very good. The calzone was huge and really full. Everyone who had pizza in my group said the crust was great. Guy working there was friendly.

LOVE this place! Excellent food, service, and people.

Sadly this place has gone down hill. Wing sauce was really lacking... no Buffalo favor or body at all. And the sheet pizza hardly any pepperoni except for the couple pieces they dumped a pile on. This was a childhood treat that is not the same anymore!