Nicholas Greek Italian - Tullahoma

My fiancé and I celebrated our anniversary here, and it was truly fantastic! The atmosphere is quiet and cozy, creating the perfect setting. They may be modest about their food, but honestly, this has been the best restaurant we've visited all year! Everything was delicious!

My husband and I dined at this restaurant last night, and we thoroughly enjoyed our meals. I had the baked spaghetti while my husband opted for the Greek spaghetti. The little Greek salad was the best I've ever tasted. We highly recommend this restaurant! Although we live in Shelbyville, we drove to Tullahoma specifically to eat here, and we’ll definitely be back soon! The service was quick, efficient, and polite, truly deserving of our business. The menu offers a wide variety of choices. Overall, it’s an excellent restaurant!

The family-oriented atmosphere is palpable. During quieter times, I’ve seen one or both kids working on their homework at a table or on a computer, which some reviewers have criticized. However, I find it charming and a testament to the parents’ commitment to their children’s education while deeply involving them in the family business. Having lived in larger cities and dined in gourmet restaurants across France, Germany, and England, as well as on luxury cruise ships staffed by skilled chefs, I value the difference that quality, fresh ingredients make in a well-prepared meal. While larger cities have their standout restaurants, the effort to discover them is always worth it. The food tends to be fresher, prepared with care and expertise, with a visible pride in the craftsmanship. At Nicholas', the salads are consistently fresh, and I’m not sure how they manage to have tomatoes year-round, but they always find their way into the salads, making them vibrant and crisp. I enjoy pairing my salad with a piece of warm pita bread. One of my favorite dishes here includes the fresh green beans, which are perfectly seasoned and cooked. I often swap out fries for green beans, as I find them a healthier and tastier option. In fact, ordering a large salad alongside a side of green beans makes for a delightful, low-calorie meal. For steak lovers, don’t miss the filet mignon served with a baked potato and green beans. The meat is always tender and cooked precisely to my liking. The seasoning here surpasses similar dishes I’ve had in larger cities that cost twice as much, and this meal is priced around $21. The pepper steak is another fantastic option that we've enjoyed on many occasions, consistently delivered with the same high quality. Desserts include a variety of options, with homemade baklava being a standout — perfectly baked to a light brown and filled with walnuts. Other desserts are sourced from a local baker, and I highly recommend trying the chocolate cake with marshmallow frosting if you’re craving something sweet, without worrying too much about calories. Furthermore, as a restaurant that focuses on personalized dining, if you have a particular meal in mind, you can call a day or two in advance to see if it can be prepared for you, depending on availability. If you're in Tullahoma and haven’t yet visited, Nicholas’ restaurant is absolutely worth your time.

Especially the food was DELICIOUS next to it had sat for a minute before I came to him, so Pita was a little dry haha, but this is my fault! They said and told me they were from one thing, but reserved their last two from another to my pickup, which was like 6 hours later! Also an article or two was overlooked in my order, but it was a HUGE folder haha, my ocd entered and I wanted to try one of EVERYTHING and a few days after I had waited to see if the charges had passed on my card and when I told them they told me that this was how I had a voucher for this article at any time I wanted them or something that corresponds to these articles, no questions! Now this is an AWESOME BUSINESS!!!! We are all people and make mistakes or we would not need our Jesus so that they were more than willing to correct it! Thank you and we will be back!!!! May God pour blessings on you!

I had the Greek salad and lamb gyro- the salad came out fast but it was definitely fresh and delicious. My lamb gyro followed in a timely manner. It came with lettuce, onions, tomatoes and taziki sauce. It was a large portion for lunch so I did take home and finish the gyro for supper. This is a small, quaint family owned restaurant. The owner is also the chef and takes pride in what he prepares. No fuss, no frills just really delicious Greek food! I would love to see some stuffed tomatoes or peppers and maybe spanakopita! I visit tullahoma regularly and will definitely be back! Great place, give it a try’