Sibley Gardens - Trenton

I dined there this past Thursday with my two brothers, and we had a fantastic dinner. The food was excellent, and our server, Nicole, was incredibly nice and helpful. Gary Asciutto.

Our bill came to nearly $600, and throughout our meal, no one checked in on us to see if we needed anything or how our food was. This was incredibly frustrating and unacceptable. We had praised Sibley Gardens to our family, as it was my husband's choice for this significant birthday, but it turned out to be a serious mistake. The food presentation was quite disappointing: the meat ravioli were enormous, measuring about 4x4 inches, and looked like something a child had made. The shrimp fettuccine had just four shrimp on top, and the scallops were similarly sparse with only four pieces. My tenderloin was served on a plain white plate for $48, and the only other item I received was a salad—no vegetables or any accompaniment to complement the meat on that large plate. The salmon was served in the same lackluster manner. Overall, the presentation was far too minimal and unappealing. If Sibley’s continues down this path of meager portions and poor service, they likely won't last long. The food was subpar, and the service was even worse. If given the chance to do it over, we definitely wouldn’t choose Sibley Gardens. We won’t be returning, nor will we recommend it to anyone—this experience was a significant waste of money! On a side note, the restaurant's accessibility for those with wheelchairs or walkers is very poor, with a long distance from the parking lot to the front door and then an inconvenient layout to enter the dining areas. Overall, it was a frustrating experience for everyone involved.

I’ve never been let down here. Everything is consistently excellent.

My favorite place in every way! The atmosphere and food are incredible! The staff and other guests are so friendly. Thank you, Sibley Gardens!

It was my first visit, and I was with a group of six. Everything was fantastic!