Il Caratello - Tavarnelle val di pesa

We visited the restaurant early on a Saturday evening. It was empty so we had the pick of tables. The waiter was attentive took drinks and food orders. The menu was very limited in choice and not much for children to eat. We all had pasta accept one of our party. The waiter it turns out was also the chef! The meals were very average, some hot from the microwave others cold. It was basic but disappointing. The meal cost 65 euros which felt overpriced for the quality. I think we with more staff the restaurant could be something, we will not be returning.

Our wedding was catered by Il Caratello and it was just amazing. The flavours are just wonderful and the staff did an excellent job by serving a large group at one time. We visited the restaurant in Tavarnelle in March to try out several dishes and everything was lovely. Try the red Stieto wine as well!

We stayed in tavarnelle by chance and we stopped at dinner. all really good cutters and the first really good. We will definitely return to get the meat.

This place was amazing! It's such a cute hole in the wall spot with a really homey feel. As a tourist, it felt like a really authentic Italian experience with true tuscan cuisine (as seen as we were surrounded by locals). First, the staff was so incredibly helpful, kind and attentive which is always great to find!! The burrata and pepper starter was absolutely delicious and packed full of tomato flavor. Free bruschetta was also provided during the meal and it was one of the best i've had, more finely chopped than most bruschettas! The gnocchi was cooked perfectly and the lasagna was pretty solid as well. I also highly recommend the pistachio dessert! It's not just gelato as it has a gooey warm center and a cookie base but it was even better than expected. I love this place and would go back in a heart beat!

We had a good dinner. The food was good and the menu focuses on local products. The service was excellent. We visited the tourist season so the restaurant was quiet. Service: Dine in Meal Type: Dinner Price per person: €20–30 Food: 4 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 3