Tony's Cafe - Taneytown

The best shrimp salad I've ever had! Try it on their underroll; everything is made in-house. The strombolis and calzones are excellent too. I've never had a bad experience here.

I am from Belgium, and I remember visiting from 1999 to 2000. The cheesesteaks were the best, and the team was wonderful!

Bought many pizzas from them. Tried somthing different. Ordered Seafood Alfredo Rosè. Around $25 dollars. It was one of the worst dishes I had. No flavor and scallops were raw inside. It was too late to return it because I was already home. I called a week later because I was in the area and explained what happened and asked if they would be willing to comp me a pizza or something just to help because I spent a lot on terrible food. They said they weren't willing to even give me a small cheese pizza. It's on me for not calling that night, but I figured a good business would be willing to work with me a little. I'm not one to complain, but it was terrible. Probably won't go there again.

THERE MUST BE A BEEK AND FISH SHORTAGE SOMEWHERE! I will never buy food from this place again. I purchased a fish sub and a steak and cheese sub and there was very little meat on both sandwiches. My husband and I stared at the food in disbelief. Some parts of the sub didn't have any meat at all.

We have ordered a few times in the last few months and no real complaints. We really like the bread they use for their subs so that's our go to. We also had their pizza. If you like NY style then it's a solid option.