The Surry Seafood Co

I am only giving 2 stars because the people in this establishment were attentive servers and friendly and great. However, for a fine dining seafood restaurant, the food was incredibly disappointed. We wait over an hour to be seated and then waited an equal hour for our food. Our food did not come to us until after 9pm. When we then learned once we finished the very plain, overpriced food, that the establishment closed at 9pm, an hour ago, and they no longer had coffee refreshments for after meal. When I say the food was plain, it was so plain. I order the company platter with a selection of seafood, my crab cake had shell in so much of it and no seasoning to taste, I may as well slurped the meat straight from the shell, the shrimp were rubber and hard, so over cooked and bland, the flounder was tasteless, mushy in the middle. Incredibly disappointing. As an appetizer we order tuna bites, that came to us so highly seasoned you cant taste the tuna and then the tuna itself was incredibly dry and over cooked. So sad. There is no recommendation for this place. I hope the server we had can find a place that matches her excellent service, for it's sad she probably suffers from the kitchens lack of quality. Also, 4 adults will easily spend over 200 for dinner, so it's a very high price to pay and long wait to be had for sadly cooked seafood. Find somewhere else to go.

A hidden gem! This beautiful restaurant sits deep off the roads of route 10 in Surry, VA. This place did not disappoint. A beautiful location surrounded by water and an atmosphere of friendly people. The view is absolutely stunning! After eating, you can enjoy walking along the pier and just take in the beauty of nature around you! The food and service was great! Fish was fresh (we had bacon wrapped salmon and fried catfish), and the best hush puppies I ever tasted. Water and tea will come in a small glass but refilled.

Our waitress was wonderful. We were a large party, and we were surprised that we were not assigned 2 servers. Sarah took our orders and each was correct (14). She was pleasant and attentive to our needs. Definitely an asset to this restaurant. There was a discrepancy on one of the bills and the manager was called for assistance. He was very nasty to her when she asked him how to resolve the issue, and the whole situation happened when the customer was standing right there. I gave a 4 for the food. I rate 5 for sevice, 0 for management.

Surry Seafood's first visit. The food was excellent. I had the seafood salad, very tasty. There were four of us and we were all full and happier. The staff was on everything and the outside seats were great. Nice place to eat. Take the Jamestown ferry makes the trip even better.

The food was amazing! I had the blue crabs for appetizer and the peace Captain Platter. The best seafood on the James River!! I definitely come back. I'd just suggest doing half a plate. It was just too much, but it was all so good!!