Carmelo's Pizzeria - St. Augustine

Best in St. Augustine by FAR! Great service as well, especially David!

After a long walk went with my family and the service was awesome ! We ordered supreme pizza and it was delicious.

Excellent NY style pizza from an unassuming location tucked behind a Shell gas station. Restaurant staff were super friendly. Will definitely be returning next time when in St. Augustine.

Ok my wife is a self proclaimed Stromboli expert and she seriously keeps talking about Carmelo's version. It's her #1 or really close. The Margherita pizza was good and would have been perfect if we ate at the restaurant rather than pick up. Just go! No regrets other than you should have gone sooner.

Delicious pizza at a great price! My family was in St. Augustine on vacation and tried this place based on a recommendation from some friends. Seemed like a place locals go for amazing pizza. Limited seating but no wait when we went. We all got pizza by the slice so we could try several variations. Everything was great! Highly recommended!!