Tigers Pizza Subs - Spring Lake

My first visit was great! The location is convenient and away from the hustle and bustle of Spring Lake. The interior has a charming shabby chic vibe. They even recognized my order before I had a chance to say my name when I walked in! We tried two different pizzas: the Tiger Pizza and a custom one. Both were delicious, made fresh to order, and packed with flavor. Overall, it was definitely a great value for the money!

The food is excellent, and the staff is outstanding—especially Bernie, who is not only the best delivery driver but also a fantastic server and now a great friend. Honestly, Tiger Pizza has it all in Spring Lake, NC!

I’m glad to be back and see that you’re still open, and the pizza is just as amazing as ever. If you’re coming from Western NY and craving pizza that tastes like home, this is the spot for you! If you’re looking for large pizzas from a small shop, this is the place to be!

So far we had only one experience, ordered a small thin crust cheese pizza and a medium-strong crust-white cheese pizza with added sausage. Not super amazing, and definitely not NY style as advertised, but the cheese mix and sauce were very beautiful. The prices were not too bad, but it is definitely more than your average chain restaurant. Must try again to see if it's worth the price difference, but now I'd say it's pretty good.

I could give a no star. I have been ordering from this place for over 7 years. I ordered one today and not once did they mentioned that they had changed their menu. I have ordered the same thing for 7 years. I called and asked when they changed the menu and he says 3 weeks ago. With that being said when I told him I was allergic to mushrooms and again never said they added to the salads. He told me next time I?ll just have to order it without it. Mind you 10.69 for the salad, 3.00 for extra cheese 1.99 for black olives. He never asked if he could replace it or leave me credit for the next time. Never again. I?m sorry