Michelangelo Of Speonk

The staff is incredibly friendly. I absolutely love their food, especially the pizza, chicken parmesan, rice balls, meatballs, and tiramisu – everything is fantastic! I'm particularly enamored with the chicken parmesan; I've had it several times and it has never been dry. It's always so tender and juicy.

Just before the pandemic, we used to visit Michelangelo in Speonk at least four times a month. We just love it! The food is outstanding! Everything is fresh and incredibly tasty. The owners and staff are absolutely wonderful and so accommodating! Their pizzas are truly top-notch. I ordered takeout last night, and once again, it was hot, delicious, and I couldn't have made it any better myself! (And I'm Italian!)

The staff here are wonderful, and the pizza, especially the specialty slices, is delicious. The heroes are also excellent; we often order them for work. My only complaint is about the balsamic dressing. No matter how I ask, I always receive a cup of cooking oil with just a splash of balsamic vinegar. My favorite is the grilled chicken hero topped with salad, but sometimes I end up with just a cup of oil instead of the dressing I wanted. I recently asked what I should specifically request to get the dressing I like—just plain balsamic vinegar, no oil. However, today I received balsamic glaze again. I wonder if there’s a language barrier causing the confusion. The sandwich itself is still great; everything is always fresh and well-prepared, which is the most important thing. But I’m still frustrated about the balsamic vinegar situation...

I love the place I just wish when I ordered a couple of slices with toppings that the pizza the toppings are being placed on weren't left out for an hour or so he should do something about that that's my only complaint everything else is beautiful

Always warm welcome! Food is excellent and portions large. Our go to for low key quality Italian food Mmmm!