Totally Baked On Sanibel

The staff was friendly, helpful, and knowledgeable, even allowing us to sample some outstanding cookies. The donuts were remarkable as well—fluffy, thick, and fresh, with great flavors. Our only critique is that the donuts were packaged in the box on their sides, which caused the toppings to get a bit messy. We would have preferred them laid flat in a single layer. We will surely be adding this café to our must-visit list for our next trip to Sanibel Island!

Incredible donuts and an amazing staff! This spot is a hidden gem among the many “mom and pop” specialty restaurants on Sanibel Island. Highly recommend their glazed donuts and chocolate-covered coconuts!

This is hands down the BEST glazed donut I've ever had! They melt in your mouth. However, they sell out quickly!

Proven breakfast sandwiches and donuts. Everyone liked their choices. I can't wait to try the sandwiches from the big roasts.

Totally baked, totally good! Crab salad on a croissant with chips. Everything is handmade to perfection. This is my go-to place for food and sweets. Yum!