Pirates Pizza - South Orange

I stopped by for pizza and wings. Was surprised to see new ownership but decided to give it a try. BIG MISTAKE!The pizza was a disaster: the dough was tasteless, the sauce very salty. I asked for the crust to be crispy but I guess that’s not clear. Not only was not crispy, he out both slices in the same box, on top of one another !The wings were dry! Appears like they were old, fried too many times!Needless to say, I won’t be coming back to this establishment.

That girl Kori is always here. She always eats the slices I have left over. I don't mind it though, great food, great service!

Pizza was average, onion rings were bad and their business practice is scammy. I ordered a half Veg/plain pizza over phone and the guy at the counter didn't care to mention about extra charges for veggie toppings and charged me 10$ extra just for toppings. While at the store, another customer in older age also mentioned she paid 22$ for her sandwich and wasn't sure why it was so expensive. There are plenty of other good pizza stores in area, this is a place to stay away from.

I’m kind of upset I took so long to try this spot. Their food is really high quality. Everything always tastes fresh, hot, and delicious. I’ve had them like 4 times now it always hits the spot. Just really good overall.

Honestly, speaking for the first time since the pandemic I can say that the food is decent. Yes, I