Fogarty's - South Berwick

I recently visited Fogarty’s for the first time, and it certainly won't be my last. The restaurant is in a quiet location away from the hustle and bustle of other dining spots. I was in town for business and turned to Yelp for recommendations, and I wasn't disappointed. The waitress was friendly and very helpful; when I asked her for her signature dish, she suggested the Lobster Pie. As a lobster lover, I can tell you it was absolute heaven! The Clam Chowder on the side was also exceptional. Considering the generous portion sizes and reasonable prices, this place is definitely worth a visit. I give it five stars!

After years, I finally returned to South Berwick for dinner and had an amazing experience! My server, Joe, was outstanding and the food was incredible. I ordered the grilled lobster stew and the caprese sandwich, which featured fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, and basil—delicious! The fried vegetables were just as good as I remembered and didn't let me down this time. We were so full that we couldn't eat another bite, but we made sure to save room for cheesecake! Thank you for a perfect evening; we’ll definitely be back for our next date night. We went at 7:00 on a Saturday and only waited twenty minutes. Trust me, you won’t regret dining here!

I've been there three times and have never had a bad meal. Everything is delicious, the prices are good, portions are generous, and the service is excellent. I highly recommend it!

Excellent food! We ordered a large order of onion rings as an appetizer not to recognize that their portion sizes are HUGE! There were enough onion rings for a small army! The burger was amazing and the house made cake beautiful treat! Wait staff super helpful and extremely nice!

Stopped in for lunch. The Butternut and Cranberry Bisque was outstanding. I had the Teriyaki Salmon with squash and Mashed potatoes my favorite veggie combo). It was super moist and delicious. Hubby had a steak, mushroom and cheese sub and said it was the best ever. We will certainly go back if we are in the area.