Broadway Bagels - South Amboy

The bagels are decent, but when it comes to breakfast sandwiches, I'm not a fan of eggs that are microwaved.

I ran 22 miles from Princeton to Parlin, and after a rough moment in a Knights of Columbus parking lot, I made it to the bay. To top off the day, I enjoyed what might be the best toasted everything bagel with cream cheese while sitting in a Prius. The staff also kindly filled up my water bottle for me, which was really thoughtful. I would definitely recommend this place—10/10!

I wouldn't describe Gems as great, but I wouldn't label it as bad either. I've ordered food from there multiple times. The bagels are decent, though I personally prefer them to be a bit crunchier on the outside. The cream cheeses are quite good, and while the breakfast sandwiches are enjoyable, they don't stand out as exceptional. The prices for the sandwiches feel a bit steep considering what you receive. Today, we tried the crumb cake, but it turned out to be undercooked. However, the Meat-Atarian sandwich is actually quite tasty, and I'd order that again. I would recommend skipping the coffee. One thing that bothers me is the lack of prices displayed, apart from the option to upgrade to a combo for an additional $4. The service can be a bit slow, but it’s understandable since the sandwiches are made fresh, and there’s usually a good number of customers there each time we visit.

New to town our teenagers are OBSESSED with the French Toast Bagel chocolate chip cookies, which will now be called “The Family Cookie” because it tastes like it was made in a loving kitchen ??

My 1st time there Today The sandwiches were good The staff was funny In a good way