Goodfella's Pizzeria - Sour Lake

Finally stop in this place; pizza is very good and can be customized to one’s liking I was expecting with the name some Mobster movie posters, but the walls are bare

Excellent place! Great pizza. Very happy to find it open on Sunday evening.

Sandwiches are over priced would of been better off going to subway. Why would anyone put lettuce on meatballs sub never ask just wouldof expect Peppers not lettuce

Bad, bad, bad pizza. The real Goodfellas would’ve (insert bad joke) put a hit out on the guy who made this pizza. Easily comparable to the Huntz Brothers gas station pizza. The ingredients were sub par quality. The dough was terribly chewy and the crust was actually inedible. We bought two specialty pizzas and threw them both away. I could’ve taken cash from my pocket and thrown it to the ground and walked away and it would’ve been put to better use than the Goodfellas Pizza went spent it on. You’ll know good pizza after you’ve had pizza this bad.

Reduced from 5 stars from my review from 2 years prior. Went yesterday and the pizza was overcooked. The entire crust on the bottom was crunchy and much of the cheese was burned solid brown. This store is almost 2 hours from home so its disappointing to say this.