Mia Mangia Pizzaria - SIREN

I mistakenly ordered a pizza from the Grantsburg location and when I arrived, the owner rudely asked, “What am I supposed to do with that pizza?” I used to work at this location under different management, where it was typical to resolve such issues by making a new pizza. When I requested to place a new order, she told me that wasn’t possible. Overall, it was an unprofessional experience, and I’ve decided to take my business elsewhere. All I did was search for Mia Mangia in Siren, Wisconsin, and inadvertently called the Grantsburg number.

The 16-inch pizza was only 14.5 inches, and the taste was just okay—not terrible, but definitely not great either. I've had better pizzas from gas stations, but it is what it is.

The pizza here is excellent, and the service is great. I highly recommend trying their pizza at least once in your life.

One of the worst pizzas I have ever tasted. It was dry, and the toppings seemed stale! The prices are way too high—$35 for a pizza and a small order of fries is outrageous.

The delightful couple who owns both the Grantsburg and Siren locations (beer and wine are available in Grantsburg) prepares the dough, sauce, and all the delectable items in-house. The restaurants are clean, the service is friendly, and the Italian menu is impressive with well-prepared dishes. My personal favorite is the large all-meat pizza with pineapple, cooked well-done and cut into slices. Definitely give their delivery a try!