Cookie Jar Bakery - Shorewood

I had to pick it up while managing my toddler and newborn, and the lady there kindly offered to carry the cookie cake for me, which was a huge help! My toddler also had a frosted sugar cookie, and I managed to sneak a bite. Honestly, it was the best cookie I've ever had in my life! I can’t stop thinking about those cookies, lol! Thank you for being so friendly and for making such delicious, fresh cookies!

I wanted to order cookies for my son's monster truck-themed birthday party, and I'm so glad I chose this bakery. They were absolutely fantastic! The cookies were delicious and fresh, and the design was exactly what I was looking for. I've been telling everyone where I got them from. Thank you, Cookie Jar Bakery, for providing such amazing cookies for our family and friends. You really did an excellent job! I can't wait to order cookies again for our next event! P.S. For anyone who hasn't visited yet, when you go to this place, the smell is incredibly tempting—you'll want to try one (or more!) of everything!

I made a last-minute order for cookie monster themed cookies for my sons first birthday. One dozen for the dessert table and one dozen to be individually packed for party favors. they turned out perfect everyone loved them they look so cute and we’re absolutely delicious I can’t wait to have an excuse to order from here again I highly recommend them!

Came back to try after the closing of Cookie Jar Bakery.. cookies are not the same. Not as good.

Local bakery with sweet treats including their main cookies (chocolate chip, peanut butter, snicker doodles and oatmeal raisin) plus lots of other goodies. Not quite as spectacular as the original owners recipes but still highly recommended.