Amy's Pizza - Shipshewana

The best pizza found in Shipshewana when I found Amys Pizza. Great friendly staff and great pizza!

The first time to eat here. I had a Phlly Beef Sub and definitely the best I ever had! Very recommended.

Pizza was great! Fried green beans roasted pickles were good. Chicken Club sub-substituted ranch for Italian dressing was so good! The service was fast. We ordered. The first time we visited. We're coming back!

I love Amys pizza friendly, clean, and a great place for date nights and they have Wi-Fi. Pizzaburgers are the best in town.

Great food, reasonable prices! I had the Stromboli, my wife had the pizza burger and we shared the garlic cheesie bread. Awesome