Sherrill New York Pizzeria

I placed an online order this evening and when I went to pick it up, the girl that was at the counter was overly busy playing with and twirling her hair. She also put her hands on the bag and container that my food was in. That’s just gross! I did consider telling her she could keep the food and to refund my payment. I’m sorry but I don’t want hair near my food, that’s why people tie their hair back when they are around food. As far as the food, it just didn’t taste good tonight. Lesson learned, I’ll think twice before I order from this establishment.

I go get slices on my lunch break at least once a week here. The pizza is absolutely amazing and the service couldn't be any better honestly. I would recommend this spot to ANYONE that loves NY style pizza!

I have ordered delivery of a gluten free meat lovers 2x . I have been working in the restaurant industry for well over 40 years . These people are on point!! highly recommend!!! order was delivered 20 minutes early both times !! The pizza was awesome ! Tip these delivery people well !!

Super friendly staff. FAST service. Many single slice options to choose from at lunchtime. Everything sauce chicken wing pizza is the best chicken wing pizza I have ever had. I will go out of my way for it! Yum!

18.50 for a large cheese there not the only pizza shop around jerky Joe's is $10 yeold pizza is $11 and d rays in Oneida is $7