Carmines Pie House - Sharpes

Out of town for a convention, first time eating here. We sat outside to eat and it was raining so hard to judge the atmosphere. The food though.. food was fantastic. Pizza was great and I had the best Oreo cake I've ever had! Service was pretty slow and we almost left but, I'm glad we stayed for that great food.

Hit or miss, inconsistent product. Usually the NY Style pizza is outstanding but today it was dry with no sauce and the crust was hard and thick. There must have been a shortage of the sauce, how hard is it to put together the components of a pizza anyway? Terrible pizza, booo.

We came at just the right time. When we were almost done, it looked like the lunch crowd coming in. Service was great and the food was amazing. Only problem we had was we didn’t get our kids Mac and cheese and had to ask a couple of times and then we were told after we were all done eating that they were all out but it was fine they just took it off the bill. We will be back, hopefully soon!

Big big portions for the but lacking flavor on the sub sandwiches

Man I've lived here 6 years and just found out about this place last week. Already been there twice. Had Mr. Richard both times. We love yall. Great food, good music, cool place. Can't wait to come back. And by the way Chicago Pie is thick