Fritzsche's Bakery - Sayville

A hidden gem on Sayville's Main Street! Everything is incredibly fresh and delicious. I love the rye bread, and on Sundays, I treat myself to some cookies for the road. There are entrances in both the front and back.

A hidden gem on Sayville's Main Street! Everything is incredibly fresh and delicious. I love the rye bread, and on Sundays, I pick up some cookies to share. The restaurant has both a front and a back entrance.

This past Sunday, we arrived just as they were closing, but there were still plenty of fresh items available for two different gatherings we were attending. The owner is incredibly hardworking, as is the entire team. I wish I had taken pictures of the delights we purchased! We got a round bundt chocolate chip cake, which, although simple with crumbs on top, was a huge hit at the party! I thoroughly enjoyed it as well. We also bought some angel wings, or elephant ears—those large, crispy pastries that probably have an Italian name. We grabbed three, and one was partially dipped in dark chocolate. I was prepared to spend over $30, but I was pleasantly surprised when our total came to only $21! This is remarkable, especially since I know that if I had bought the same items at Alpine Bakery in Smithtown, it would’ve cost over $30. This bakery is located in the charming town of Sayville. It might be a hidden gem, or perhaps the locals are well aware of it. Either way, I was incredibly impressed, and we will definitely be returning! A huge thank you to the owner(s) for their hard work—everything we bought was delicious, even at closing time.

Visiting my hometown of Sayville. Ordered a variety of different bakery goods. All were so compromised in quality ingredients. It’s too bad.

This is what you call an old-school Bakery I've been to at least 50 bakeries out here trying to find cookies that had the taste of when I was a kid I knew there had to be one on Long Island I finally found it these cookies are the real deal no grocery store cookie I must have passed this place a dozen times it is very small never even noticed it a neighbor told me about this Bakery and I still had trouble finding it for some reason it never came up on Google thankfully I found it five stars to the Baker and his recipe