Eli Pizzeria - Sayville

The pizza is absolutely incredible, and the other dishes are equally fantastic, leaving me craving more of the delicious flavors they create. The owner and chef are wonderful and engaging, which is crucial for a successful restaurant experience. Just writing this makes me hungry for their amazing food!

I’m not usually a fan of pizza since I'm quite particular about the sauce consistency. However, this place is amazing! Their pizza is fantastic! I haven’t tried the other menu items, but I’m sure they’re just as good as any other dish I’ve experienced. Plus, the owners are wonderful people with kind hearts. I visit every week with a young man with special needs, and they always greet us with warm smiles and engaging conversations. Highly recommended!

Good energy comes from this pizzeria. Very friendly owner and excellent service. He offered me a hot sauce to try with my Auberginen-Pamigiana disc, and it really hit the place. Next time I will try the chicken taco slice because that sounds like a better slice with hot sauce. Oh, by the way, this place is NOT a demolition. I have two special discs and a can soda for $10.27, which after taxes... and being honest, that's like two meals. These pizzas are full of toppings.

Fine pizza, wonderful garlic knots and amazing food overall. The generosity of the employees is above the top. This is the only pizza place I'm going to!

This place is great. I love the pepperoni wheels, and the pizza itself is great as well. And the guys who work here are friendly, awesome, and hard-working. Great place to swing by!