Rita's Italian Ice - Sayreville

The ice and custard here are always consistently great. I really enjoy this particular Rita's because it's always busy, and the service is quick. They always make an effort to assist you, even if you're looking for something outside the usual options.

Please support this location; the owner, manager, and staff genuinely care about customer service! I visited on their opening day with my 3-year-old, and after placing my order, I quickly realized I had forgotten my wallet at home. I informed the employee to set my order aside, and I would return to pay. The owner overheard and told me to take the ice cream and come back later to settle the payment. I was initially concerned about this arrangement, but it was clear that he was more worried about me and my little one. This experience truly reflects the excellent service this business offers. We will definitely continue to support this Rita!

The staff at this restaurant is exceptionally friendly, which really sets it apart. It's a gem to see such a dedicated team of young adults working hard to ensure everything runs smoothly. I appreciate how welcoming they made my visit, making my travels enjoyable and pleasant. Thank you!

I love the ice. Today back there!