Goodfellas Cafe Winery - Sarasota

Goodfellas pizza is incredible. Best pie in Florida that I have had. Ask for Nash, hes the man!

My family was very impressed with Goodfellas. I am a fan of authentic New York-style pizza, which is difficult to find back home. The pizza was delicious! The made-to-order cannolis were even better and were a huge hit with the entire family. We ordered takeout and were pleased with the friendly service. We will definitely be going back again!

1st time there tonight. Drove up from Venice. The BEST pizza we have had since we moved here from Wisconsin. The wine is also FANTASTIC. Bought 2 bottles for home Will definitely go back!!

So yummy. Crispy thin- I was brought up on midwest thin pizza.

I absolutely adore this place. We stumbled upon it while on our way to a club and now we make it a weekly tradition. The thin crust pizza is delightful and the personal size portions allow me to customize my order while my wife can do the same. We have even started bringing our friends along and they have all fallen in love with it too.