Pennocks Icecream - Sackets Harbor

I am from Kentucky and I asked for Butter Pecan ice cream and when I said it she rudely corrected me and said i was wrong because I didn’t pronounce it how she did and then proceeded to call me d and i’m 14. DO NOT RECOMMEND

The greatest ice cream shop this side of rhe Mississippi.

Best ice cream ever! Visit from Nashville every year, and this is our spot! Great service!

We have been coming here forever. The last two years it hasn't been as good. This year it was just not good. The cookie dough ice cream was chalky tasting and the soft serve just tasted off. Scoops are small compared to local ice cream businesses.

The best. I would come here as a kid after going to wescotts beach.It the best. And the flavor burst. The are impossible to find. I have looked. And looked.Traveled over 1000miles and this is the best stop!!