American Prime - Rye Brook

The food was excellent both the appetizers and the entrees . The staff were pleasant and attentive without hovering . They allowed us to bring in our own cake for my husbands birthday, then brought us out complimentary champagne. A very positive experience, a perfect night . Would highly recommend.

This was our first time at American Prime. There is plenty of seating .... decor is lovely, dark wood, leather seating. Our waitress was very nice but the dishes sat on the table a bit longer than they should have and we did have to ask for a refill of water. This is an expensive restaurant, so one would think the food would be amazing. I ordered the strip steak (medium) and it was overcooked. My husband ordered the pork chop and said it was overcooked as well. My mom ordered the branzino which she liked very much, there was just not enough of it!! The entree's did not come with anything and the sides are $10 plus! Once is good, but we wont be back!

Went to American Prime for restaurant week to try something new. They were extremely cheap with portions. I feel like they cut what would be normal portions in half. Mussels which cost next to nothing, even the cheesecake. Not going to return.

The food was excellent, plentiful and delicious. The staff were courteous and attentive.

Food was great, service has excellent especially our waiters Shay and Willie Diamonds made our experience memorable. We dined 2 times during HVRW. Both times were Great. Will definitely return .