Tilda's Bake Shop - Rocky Point

The design of the cake was perfect, and my mom loved it, but the taste was not what we expected. My family has ordered many cakes from here before; for my son's baptism in March, the cake was a huge hit and everyone enjoyed it. However, the cake we ordered for my mom's surprise 50th birthday was a letdown—it wasn't mocha or tres leches, and it turned out to be quite dry. This was very disappointing. I hope that next time I order a cake, I might receive a discount or some kind of compensation. When I called to voice my concerns, they just took my number. Additionally, I had ordered a cake that was supposed to be all strawberry, but it ended up being half pineapple and half strawberry if I remember correctly!

I ordered my gender reveal cake from Tilda's this past weekend, and I was thrilled with the experience! The cake was not only beautifully decorated but also absolutely delicious. Amanda at the counter was incredibly helpful, especially since I had no idea what I wanted. She guided me through the entire process, from placing my order to receiving the gender results and even decorating the cake. It was my first visit to the bakery, and I will definitely return for more treats!

This is the best bakery I've ever been to! Every time we go to Jersey, I end up bringing back eight loaves of bread, not to mention all the pastries! But the spindles are absolutely amazing!

Like everywhere else, the prices have increased and the product sizes have decreased except for the black-and-white cookies though come and they are awesome and quite large for $3

Always a great selection of desserts and friendly staff.