Mr. Miceli Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant

My buddies and I visited NY during the Memorial Day 2012. We tried several pizzerias during our vacation. Mr. Miceli was working when we found his place (by smell). We each had a couple of slices and it was excellent. I then asked Mr. Miceli if i could purchase 2 pies to bring back to SC. He had 2pies wrapped (each slice individually wrapped). The 2 pies made it back to SC and was fantastic. I returned a week ago to help some people in East Rockaway with cleanup from Sandy. Before we left we stopped by Mr.Miceli's and purchased another pie to bring home. If you want the best pizza in NY, stop by Mr.Miceli's! You will take a pie home also.

My buddies and I visited NY during the Memorial Day 2012. We tried several pizzerias during our vacation. Mr. Miceli was working when we found his place (by smell). We each had a couple of slices and it was excellent. I then asked Mr. Miceli if i could purchase 2 pies to bring back to SC. He had 2pies wrapped (each slice individually wrapped). The 2 pies made it back to SC and was fantastic. I returned a week ago to help some people in East Rockaway with cleanup from Sandy. Before we left we stopped by Mr.Miceli's and purchased another pie to bring home. If you want the best pizza in NY, stop by Mr. Miceli's! You will take a pie home also.

To be honest, I'm a firm believer in the existence of 'Competition-based fake reviews'.

Over priced & not very good which was very disappointing since we were visiting from the West Coast & were looking forward to some authentic NY pizza.

The pizza was very overpriced and was burnt also it took a half an hour to come out and also they ripped us off Don't go here the worker was super rude