Insomnia Cookies - Rochester

The cookies here are delicious and come in a great variety of flavors. The staff is friendly and helpful. While the prices are a bit lower than Crumbl, I noticed that the cookies are also smaller in size. Overall, it's a great spot to satisfy your cookie cravings!

The cookies were well-made, but the selection of ice cream was quite limited. I ordered a “cookiewich” and would love the chance to choose from new cookie flavors like Pumpkin Latte and Matcha Latte, rather than just the classic options for the ice cream sandwich.

Amazing cookies, definitely expensive, so I only give them for special occasions. During my last visit, the customer service was not good, but I just cleaned it off. I think a reward system would be really nice.

Oh my gosh! Insomnia Cookies has the best cookies in Rochester, in my opinion! They deliver until 2 AM, and their cookies are absolutely delicious. They also offer ice cream, cookie sandwiches, vegan and gluten-free options, brownies, and a variety of large biscuits. You really need to try them—you won't be disappointed! Plus, the delivery drivers are really nice and very quick! I actually received my order just now (pictures below).

I received a complimentary extra cookie, and I'm really enjoying this place much more than Crumbl. The quality is better, it's conveniently located near my home, and the portion sizes are generous. The deluxe cookies are enormous and definitely worth the extra cost.