Fat Zach's Pizza Downtown Puyallup

The No Big Dill pizza is absolutely delicious, and this place is fantastic! Food: 5/5

The pizza here is fantastic! I tried the Outlaw and the cheese bread, and both were absolutely delicious. However, their approach to handling issues was less than ideal. The ice machine for the soda was out of order, and instead of having a server manage the drinks, they set up a communal ice bucket with a tin cup. Customers were expected to dig into the ice with their hands and scoop their own ice. Upon our request, they swapped our three self-serve drinks for a 2-liter bottle of soda, which was a much better solution. The community ice bucket concept definitely needs improvement; I’m sure the health department would agree. Apart from that, we had a positive experience. The indoor and outdoor dining atmosphere was lovely, and they played classic rock music at a perfect volume. We will definitely come back!

We hired Fat Zach's for our wedding on 7-15-23. Prior to that, we had visited the restaurant near the fairgrounds a handful of times. Every interaction has been a positive experience! At the restaurant they are always friendly and the food comes quickly. And the FOOD! The pizza is our favorite, as well as the breadsticks. My wife enjoys the pickle pizza and I enjoy the chicken bacon ranch. As for our wedding, the whole experience was great from our tasting to the planning to the actual day. Fat Zach's went above and beyond, arriving early, accommodating various dietary restrictions, having the food ready in time, and then boxing up all the leftovers. The employees were kind and friendly and helped answer any of our questions. We highly recommend Fat Zach's for pizza night or your big day!

I’m here to tell you there is a whole lot more than just great pizza at this restaurant. Fat Zach’s Pizza will leave you full but with an appetite for more. The atmosphere is family friendly, (feels safe) a lot can be said about that nowadays. The staff are so friendly, and I’m always feeling good about my choice to support this business. They also support so many local charities that makes the pizza taste better somehow. I have been a returning customer for years and will continue to do so.

Husband got the pickle pizza and really liked it. Prices for the pizza weren't terrible but skip the wings. Very small legs and wings for the price. Flavor was good though.Food: 4/5