Old Town Pizza - Port Jefferson Station

We frequently order from Old Town and absolutely love the stuffed rigatoni and grilled chicken salad. I could rave about the food for ages; we've genuinely never had a bad experience. The pizza slices are outstanding, too!

I ordered a large grilled chicken salad, but they mistakenly sent me a Caesar salad. Despite the mix-up, I still enjoyed the meal. The food was fresh and fantastic!

Old Town consistently meets all my specific food requests!

I love this pizza! healthy but delicious option!!! I'm hooked!!!

The naked clams and pizzette were quite good. However, the side order of meatballs had a peculiar taste and wasn't very appetizing. Additionally, the cannoli shell was stale.