Brown Butter Cookie Company

I thought I found my favorite brown butter cookie store-NOT!!! Went to Paso Robles last week. Cute storefront, Chalky and dry expensive little cookies !! The brunette cookie clerk had the personality of a dead fish. Will NEVER go back there again.

The Brown Butter Cookie Company sets the bar for the cookie experience. It’s such a treat to be able to come in and sample all the different flavors. The cookies are exceptional. Addictive. The sisters who launched this brand are brilliant. I’m such a fan!!!!

This is a quaint shop located across the park. Free on street parking with handicap parking and handicap access available. Very nice and inviting interior. Neat clean and organized. All goodies are displayed with prices. Phoenix the server was very nice, friendly and patient. She let us take our time. She offered samples which were delicious. Hubby bought the Ghiradeli package which included peanut butter, classic shortbread, chocolate shortbread. They sell fay old discounted cookies. Store opened at 11am.

The cookie was too salty. If you like salty cookies, welcome! Too expensive to 6 little salty cookies for 9 dollars. I was not happy. I threw more than half of my cookies away.

Visited March 11, 2024. We were greeted immediately upon entry; friendly employees. We bought a six pack of brown butter and two pack of oatmeal cookies. Oatmeal cookie was average but edible. Very odd texture to the brown butter cookie. Like what eating fine sand might be like. No flavor or at least a little too delicate for my tastebuds. We tossed the rest of the package in search of more satisfying calories. Store felt dimly lit and could use a little personality. Unimaginative stacks of cookie packages on tables. I remember coming here pre-pandemic and having a different experience. I went to the web site to see if there was a change in ownership. Same owners but new production facility. Maybe this has been impactful? We paid $16 for the six brown butter and two oatmeal cookies.